On this day, February 1, 2004, Justin Timberlake punctuates the Super Bowl halftime show by tearing away part of Janet Jackson’s costume, revealing her right breast to a massive audience that quickly reaches for their TiVos for a replay. Both artists blame it on a “wardrobe malfunction,” but while Jackson gets blacklisted, Timberlake is welcomed back by the music industry and the NFL after a series of apologies.